On this page
In short: Kartari is Sanskrit for 'scissors'. When planets occupy the signs on both sides of a point in the chart, the 12th and 2nd from it, that point is caught between two blades. If both blades are natural benefics the result is shubha kartari, a protective embrace; if both are natural malefics it is papa kartari, a squeeze. The idea is applied above all to the ascendant and the Moon, but any house or planet can be tested.
The scissors image
Think of a sign in the chart as a doorway. The sign behind it (the 12th from it) and the sign in front of it (the 2nd) are the two doorposts. Planets standing on both posts frame whatever passes through. Gentle planets on both sides shelter it; harsh planets on both sides crowd it. A planet on only one side does not form kartari at all; the whole point of the image is that the hemmed place has company on both flanks.
Formation conditions
- Shubha kartari: at least one natural benefic in the 12th from the reference point and at least one natural benefic in the 2nd from it.
- Papa kartari: at least one natural malefic in the 12th and at least one in the 2nd.
- Mixed flanks (a benefic on one side, a malefic on the other) form neither, and are read planet by planet.
- Reference points: the lagna first, then the Moon, then any house whose affairs are in question, such as the 7th for marriage or the 10th for career.
Natural benefics for this purpose are Jupiter, Venus, an unafflicted Mercury and a waxing, bright Moon. Natural malefics are Saturn, Mars, Rahu, Ketu, an afflicted Mercury, a dark Moon and, in most authors' practice, the Sun.
Worked example: Virgo rising
Consider this illustrative chart with Virgo on the ascendant:
| Sign (house) | Planets |
|---|---|
| Virgo (1st) | Sun, Mercury |
| Libra (2nd) | Venus |
| Scorpio (3rd) | Mars |
| Sagittarius (4th) | Moon |
| Capricorn (5th) | Rahu |
| Cancer (11th) | Ketu |
| Taurus (9th) | Saturn |
| Leo (12th) | Jupiter |
The positions are astronomically consistent: Mercury shares the Sun's sign, Venus is one sign ahead of it, and with the Sun in the lagna the birth would fall near sunrise.
The lagna. The 12th from Virgo is Leo, holding Jupiter; the 2nd is Libra, holding Venus in its own sign. Both flanks carry natural benefics, so the lagna, and the Sun and Mercury inside it, sit in shubha kartari. Classical descriptions of this position speak of good health, protection from adversity, help from others and a comfortable bearing. Mercury, exalted in Virgo and lord of the lagna, benefits most.
The Moon. The 12th from Sagittarius is Scorpio, with Mars; the 2nd is Capricorn, with Rahu. Both are malefics, so the Moon is in papa kartari. Read alone, that describes a mind under pressure from both sides: worry about the past and the future, or emotional life squeezed between duties.
What softens it. Jupiter in Leo casts its 5th aspect onto Sagittarius, so the hemmed Moon receives Jupiter's aspect, which nearly every author counts as relief. The Moon is also waxing, about three signs ahead of the Sun, and it sits in Jupiter's own sign. An astrologer would therefore describe a steady outer life with an inner life that runs hotter than it looks, eased by faith, learning or a trusted adviser.
The same chart thus carries both kinds of kartari at once, which is common and a good reason never to read one in isolation.
How strength is judged
- How many planets are on each blade. Two benefics on each side are stronger than one; a single weak planet on one side makes a thin yoga.
- Their dignity. Venus in Libra and Jupiter in a friendly sign, as above, protect more than a debilitated benefic would.
- Their functional role for the ascendant. A natural benefic that rules the 6th, 8th or 12th for the chart is a mixed blessing even on the "good" side.
- Relief inside the hemmed house. A benefic sitting in the hemmed sign, or Jupiter aspecting it, softens papa kartari; a malefic inside sharpens it.
- Distance in degrees. Planets close by degree to the hemmed point press harder than planets at the far edges of the neighbouring signs.
Kartari beyond the lagna
Applied to the 7th house it is read for marriage and partnership; applied to the 10th, for career conditions; applied to the 4th, for home and peace of mind. Planets can be hemmed too: a Venus caught between Saturn and Mars is read as affection under strain, while a Saturn framed by Jupiter and Venus is a hard planet given cushioning.
The concept also appears in Jaimini astrology in a related form. There, planets in the 2nd from a house create argala (intervention), while planets in the 12th obstruct that intervention, which shows how both systems give the two neighbouring signs special force.
For the Moon specifically, the lunar yogas offer finer detail: planets only in the 2nd from the Moon form Sunapha, only in the 12th Anapha, and on both sides Durudhara. Kartari adds the benefic-or-malefic dimension to that picture.
Timing
The yoga becomes noticeable in the periods of the hemming planets. In the Virgo example, Jupiter's sixteen-year mahadasha and Venus's twenty-year one bring the protective side forward; the Jupiter–Venus and Venus–Jupiter sub-periods each run about two years and eight months. The Moon's papa kartari is felt more in the Mars, Rahu and Moon periods, and Jupiter's role in softening it is clearest during its own periods.
Reading it sensibly
Shubha kartari is a gentle plus, not a shield against every hardship, and papa kartari is a pressure point, not a sentence. The practical value of the yoga is that it shows where a person has natural support around them and where they may need to build some: routines that ease a crowded mind, people who share a load, time set aside for rest.
Related yogas
- Sunapha, Anapha and Durudhara Yogas — planets in the 2nd, 12th or both from the Moon.
- Vesi, Vasi and Ubhayachari Yogas — the same idea measured from the Sun.
- Amala Yoga — a benefic in the 10th from the lagna or Moon.
- Parvata Yoga — benefics in angles with the 6th and 8th empty or benefic-occupied.
- Kemadruma Yoga — the opposite condition for the Moon, with both flanks empty.
FAQ
What is papa kartari on the Moon? Natural malefics in both the 12th and 2nd signs from the Moon. It is traditionally read as pressure on the mind and emotions. A benefic with the Moon, or Jupiter's aspect on it, is the usual relief.
Does the Sun count as a malefic here? In most authors' practice it does, so the Sun on one flank and Saturn on the other would form papa kartari. A few writers treat the Sun more leniently, which is one of several small differences between schools.
Sources
- Phaladeepika of Mantreswara, ch. 6 (yogas)
- Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, ch. 36 (Santhanam)
Written by Sunyra Editorial. Astrology is a tradition of interpretation; read this as guidance, not a forecast. Disclaimer.
Last updated